Ben plans to ask Kate to move in with him and all seems fine until Kate's high school boyfriend shows up and reveals that due to a clerical error, he and Kate are technically still married, the result of a dare on a trip to Niagra falls many years ago. This makes Ben realizes that there are plenty of things they don't know about one another and they need to slow down. Connie's dad is getting married to a woman Connie hates so she invites Larry to the wedding as a fake date so her parents can freely be critical of him. But to her surprise, her dad likes Larry and he defends Connie to her new stepmother. Both Larry and Connie are rattled by the fact that they have some feelings for each other. However, things get complicated when Tiffany who is getting divorced, looks for comfort in Larry and kisses him and Connie witnesses the moment.