Kevin, Joe and Nick audition for The Three Musketeers and land the lead roles, but stage fright gets the best of Joe and he drops out of the play. Joe immediately regrets his decision as he becomes increasingly jealous of Stella's (Chelsea Staub) crush on school jock Van Dyke Tosh (Chuck Hittinger) who has replaced him as the third musketeer. Meanwhile, Macy (Nicole Anderson) loses her good luck charm and feels it is the reason behind her losing streak.