Greek Episode 3.13 Take Me Out

It's co-ed softball time on Greek Row, and the winner gets five more points toward House of the Year. Ashleigh and Casey are determined to shake their fourth-ish status and get back at the Gamma Psis. But which frat to team with? Casey's got a fave, obvs, but Ashleigh's looking for a new bot toy and, oh, yeah -- she wants to win. At the KT house, Casey tells Cappie she's cleaning his pit of a room because Ashleigh's been complaining about her "secondhand smell." Cap thinks Ash should just date a KT. How about Beaver? Casey tries to say no, for Ashleigh's sake, but her will is no match for Cap's charm. The foursome hits the batting cages to prep for the game. Beaver "subtly" hitting on Ashleigh is both painful and hilarious. When Cappie asks the girls to team with KT for the tournament, Ash calls a conference with Casey in the bathroom and explains that, cute as the Beav is, he's not her type mentally. Just then, Gamma Psis Natalie and Katherine show up. Are they still bitter about the fire? Yup. They ask who ZBZ is playing with, and Ashleigh says they're not sure yet. Rusty may be coming into his own as KT pledge educator, but Calvin's not happy that they haven't been hanging much. Rusty tries to be polite but, the fact is, he can't stand Grant. After all, Grant did duct-tape Rusty to a wall, and then he accidentally inspired Jordan to move away. Calvin begs them to give hanging a shot, and they agree... reluctantly. At Dobler's, Rusty tries to make a small talk by asking about the tiara incident. Calvin's still blowing it off as a prank, but Grant's still mad. Rusty tries to side with his friend, but that only makes everyone more miserable. Calvin and Rusty's next brah-date is around the KT pool table, sans Grant. Heath happens by and, as he and Calvin catch up, Rusty tries not-so-subtly to spark a love reconnection between these old flames. Calvin's not amused and leaves. Later, Rusty drops by the OX house to apologize, but he makes it worse by revealing Calvin's past with Heath to Grant. When one of the Omega Chis makes a gay slur in passing, however, Rusty realizes Calvin and Grant have bigger problems than him. Rebecca takes Evan to a posh restaurant for their first date. He says he'll get the next date -- uh, like a movie? He thinks doing the whole relationship thing in reverse is cool: sex, nice dinner, then a movie. Maybe it'll be love at first sight after that? But Bex says she doesn't believe in love. So he's determined to prove her wrong, of course. At their next date, "The Princess Bride," Rebecca tears up a little but clings to her no-love position. Led by handsome Pete, the Omega Chis show up at ZBZ during breakfast to formally ask them to partner for the tournament.Evan happens to be there already, so he sneaks downstairs and joins his brothers. Casey can only watch as the girls almost unanimously vote yes. Ashleigh officially accepts, tossing Pete a flirty vibe. Later she points out to a disappointed Casey that this invite means the house is on its way back! Later, Casey and Cappie realize going toe-to-toe with each other could be kinda hot. The falmes only get hotter when Cappie counterattacks by partnering with Gamma Psi. And, hello -- the two teams are facing off in the first round. Game day! The grudge match of the century starts, and the first run is a close call by Rusty. A fight nearly breaks out at home plate, but when an Omega Chi says the call was "gay," Grant calls him on it. As the OXs turn on each other, the KTs just watch and laugh. Calvin tries to talk his boyfriend down, but Rusty actually thinks Grant's right for standing up to his brother. At the bottom of the last inning, the ZBZ/OXs are down by two outs and two players on base. Cappie's told Case that he puts love first and would throw the game for her; would she do the same? At bat, facing him on the pitcher's mound, she has to choose between her sisters and her boyfriend. Strike one! Strike two! Strike ... nope! Casey hits a homer and brings in the win. But as cherring teammates surround her and Cappie walks away disappointed, she wonders if it was worth it. Later at Dobler's, all four houses reluctantly celebrate together. Cappie gets Casey to admit she might be just a little competitive -- but says he loves that about her. Ashleigh gets Rebecca and Evan to double-date with her and handsome Pete, and Rusty and Grant find some common ground. Back on the row, the KT pledges, guided by pledge educator Rusty, begin a reenactment of "A League of Their Own" for the houses's amusement. Over at ZBZ, while getting ready for bed, Casey admits she's bummed about Ash's OX boy and her double date. What's really got her down, though, is that she actually considered throwing the game for Cappie. She wonders where you have to draw the line with love, but neither girl has an answer. And the post-expulsions drama between Evan and Cappie takes on a new twist: After their feud boils over at an Amphora meeting, they find themselves summarily drummed out of the secret society. Goodbye to all that.