Lockhart/Gardner defends the operator of an adultery website against doe-eyed prosecutor Nancy Crozier. Feeling that Alicia's story helps the client seem more sympathetic, Will makes her first chair. But what seems like a simple civil case turns criminal when Crozier works with Cary to pin a murder on L/G's client as well.

No longer on speaking terms with Alicia, Kalinda contemplates leaving the firm.