After Fiona's brush with death in "Long Way Back" (Episode 309), Michael tries to nurse her back to health. Sam helps Michael search for information in Strickler's cell phone, which leads to a mysterious contact.

Meanwhile, Michael takes the case of a woman whose husband died in an insurance fraud scam. If Michael can get the victim's medical files from a health clinic, they can put a pattern together and blow the entire scam wide open. They run into a roadblock when Sam's charm isn't enough to get the files from a sixty-five year old file clerk, and Michael is forced to call in only reinforcement at his disposal: Madeline.