Harry Connick Jr. Questions 'American Idol' Judge's Capabilities

Harry Connick Jr.

The singer particularly points his comment to Simon Cowell who does not have singing background, claiming his replacement should be a musician.

Harry Connick Jr. has questioned Simon Cowell's capabilities to judge budding talent on reality shows like "American Idol" because the music mogul has no singing background of his own. The singer/actor admires Cowell but admits he would like to see a musician replace the Brit as a judge on "American Idol" next season, instead of another sharp-tongued critic.

Connick, Jr, who himself is among the names billed as a potential Cowell replacement, says, "He was amazing on that show but I also think he's not a musician, and when you don't have a musical background, you have to resort to different ways to get your point across." He adds, "He can't say, 'You're singing out of tune', when he may not know if you're singing out of tune."

TV executives are currently searching for a replacement for Cowell on "American Idol" following his decision to quit this year. Connick, Jr. became an overnight favorite when he mentored finalists for an episode on the most recent season of the show.

© AceShowbiz.com


    I Smell Poop
    Oct 01, 2010

    It was very gentlemanly of Simon not to respond with the fact that Connick Jr isn't from New Orleans and had his whole career handed to him by his father who is or was one of the presidents of Sony Music and a stockholder in Sony Pictures. Simon made the show the success it is! In truth, Connick Jr couldn't have made it through the initial Idol auditions because he's dreadful live!

    Aug 12, 2010

    I think Harry would be a great addition to Idol!!! Fox should think I mean are they CRAZY Jessica Simpson!

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked with *