After being dumped by Andi Dorfman in the season 10 finale of "The Bachelorette", Nick Viall reunited with Andi in the "Bachelorette: After the Final Rose" special. Nick had so many questions in his head and wanted to meet Andi during the "Men Tell All", but Andi wasn't ready at the time so he wrote her a letter that host Chris Harrison passed on her.
Now, Andi and Nick met face-to-face. Nick claimed he was blindsided because Andi gave him so many reasons to believe that he's the one. Asked if she ever loved him, Andi bluntly said no. "The hard part is...feeling like you did," Nick said, before making the shocking revelation that he and Andi had sex during the Fantasy Suite date.
"If you weren't in love with me, I'm just not sure why you made love with me?" he asked. Andi called the question "below the belt" and said that it should remain private, adding that their relationship was real but he might interpret individual acts differently than her. He said that what they did was "fiance-type stuff" for him.
Nick hadn't got his closure but Chris interrupted it to continue with the next segment. Andi and Josh Murray finally appeared as a couple in public for the first time. They gushed about how much they loved each other and revealed that they secretly met up in Atlanta in disguise since they finished filming the show. Andi once again denied the pregnancy rumor and said that they're eying a spring wedding.