WHAT'S HOT?

'The X Factor' Result: Rachel Crow Sent Home by America's Votes

December 09, 2011 03:07:46 GMT

The judges' votes end in a tie for Rachel and Marcus Canty, but the former is eliminated based on who is getting the lowest votes from viewers.


'The X Factor' Result: Rachel Crow Sent Home by America's Votes
See larger image

The judges were forced to make a hard decision on "The X Factor (US)" top 5 result show. Following the Wednesday performance show, it was revealed on Thursday, December 8 that Marcus Canty and Rachel Crowe landed on the bottom two.

Marcus, who was also on the verge of getting eliminated a week ago, sang "I'm Goin' Down" for his survival performance. As for Rachel, the 13-year-old girl who appeared among the standouts since the beginning opted to deliver "I'd Rather Go Blind".

When it's time for the judges to decide who would be sent home, L.A. Reid and Simon Cowell chose to save their own act as usual with the former rooting for Marcus and the latter voting for Rachel. Paula Abdul gave her vote to Rachel, leaving Nicole Scherzinger to make the deciding vote.

"I can't make this decision," emotional Nicole said. "I'll have to go to a deadlock." After host Steve Jones once again reminded her about the rules, the former member of The Pussycat Dolls tearfully chose to send home Rachel to make it a tie.

It was later revealed that Rachel had to end her journey on the show because she got the lowest number of votes from America. Breaking into tears after learning her fate, the young singer took a few moment before thanking her loyal supporters and said, "I know this is not my ending."

Next week, Marcus, Melanie Amaro, Josh Krajcik and Chris Rene will continue their battle on the semifinal round to determine who will make it to the finals. HollywoodLife recently reported that Mariah Carey has been tapped as a musical guest on the December 22 final result show.

Marcus Canty's survival performance:


Rachel Crow's survival performance:


© AceShowbiz.com




Post Your Comments

posted by Oz21 on Jan 05, 2012
It's a contest, was Rachel aware of this before she joined. It is an elimination process, what a bratttt!!!! some will win someone will lose that's life (even you're the best in what you do, you can still lose). As for that stupid Nicole, she may have been paid also to act like and say ah ah ah can't make a decision!! What a stupid looking cow, she thought the show was about her!!! Now the hatred towards her is pulsating from millions of viewers around the world (not only in America), she makes watching the show very painful. Good bye X Fucktor!
posted by OZ 21 on Jan 05, 2012
Is it for the show rating that Nicole has to act an idiot or is she really is an idiot without any brains ... beauty to no brains... she was practicing her acting skills ... bullshit ... I can't make this decision... anyone could. I hope she will be off from the panel, it would make watching X Factor much better without her ...
posted by Nelida on Dec 16, 2011
Rachel eres una estrella. Y Nicole no fue profesional a la hora de emitir su voto.
posted by Rachel Fan on Dec 14, 2011
Hey all, We all loved Rachel and she will do just fine based on her talent. My concern is when she screamed at her mom "You promise me" as if any Mom could promise a win and putting her loss on her Mom who supported her through all of this. It made her look bratty. Also, when she told her fans, "without you I am nothing" I hope she doesn't really believe that because fame is fleeting and we have a whole fleet of washed up child stars who believe that as well. I hope she does believe she's something with or without the fame or fans.
posted by Lovenit on Dec 13, 2011
Oh the drama! I love it!!!
posted by X Factor Fan on Dec 12, 2011
The problem is that the Host should not have told that Disney was really looking at Rachael. This makes voters think that she is going to be famous anyway or she is definitley going to stay so they vote another. Some people even vote the underdog. The show hurt Rachael by giving out this news. Also Niclole what were you thinking? Reason I know this is because this is what I was thinking. Now she gets the lowest votes.
posted by Bothered on Dec 11, 2011
Simon, can America vote to say that we'd like to boot off Nicole and see a different judge in her place next year? The judges should do what they're paid to do. . . judge. If you want this different than AI, please get rid of Nicole. It made sense when you used deadlock because Canty and Bell were close that night. However, this performance was a no-brainer and Nicole's reasoning, and your denfense of her reasoning, is disappointing.
posted by DEB on Dec 10, 2011
I was very upset when they voted Rachel off.. La reed is a fool. nicole took the easy way out , she alway been a marcus fan .. La did not voted for the beat one he voted for his boy.. it was a sad day .. i not going to watch anymore ,
posted by dgrace on Dec 10, 2011
That's if for this season of XFactor. The only reason I continued to watch is to see Rachel. She is full of energy, happy, and amazing. Nicole, however, is a chicken. If you are going to sling around insults, then pull up your big girl panties and make a decision... Nicole needs to understand that the show is not all about her. She's just anoying!
posted by Julie on Dec 10, 2011
Please let's take responsibility. Why should a talented singer like Rachel be in the bottom two. That's the foundation of the problem. Nicole is not to blame.
posted by John on Dec 10, 2011
America sent Rachel home not Nicole, even Nicole looked shocked.
posted by Theresa on Dec 10, 2011
IM SO PISSED AT XFACTOR FOR SENDING HER HOME SHE IS BETTER THEN ALOT OF THEM ON THAT SHOW. SO THE ONES THAT ARE LEFT ARE NOT AS GOOD AS HER IS MY FEELING AND IM SO PISSED AT THIS SHOW FOR KEEPING SOMEONE WHO CANT SING LIKE HER AT ALL HE WISHES
posted by goodness on Dec 10, 2011
Indeed Rachel should have gotten it, but she was in the bottom two for a reason no matter what our opinion is. I know Nichole should have voted, but the rules did allow America to vote so you cannot blame the judges entirely. If anything America is to blame because I know their were alot more people out there who didn't vote that loved Rachel to pieces. Rachel has such a great voice though, we all know this is not the end for her. Best of Luck in your new career Rachel!
posted by amazing123 on Dec 10, 2011
Nicole and LA should not be voted off of the show. Although voting Rachel off made them look bad.
posted by Ryosan on Dec 09, 2011
All I can say is that Nicole is a talentless loser who If she had any integrity would step down, because anyone can make the decision you made. Did you not hear or watch any of the performances? I hope this haunts you.
posted by chimperymom on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole you know in your heart of hearts Rachel sang her heart out and was twenty times better tan Marcus tonight. You should of judged the performance.
posted by Coley123 on Dec 09, 2011
I think Nicole did the right thing. it is obvious that Marcus is much better than Rachel. So she didn't want to lose a talent who is a star. To talk frankly Rachel is not a star. he is a star, that is needed in the xfactor!
posted by Kew1253 on Dec 09, 2011
Totally disappointment, more so in the judges than anything else. If it billed as a sing off that is what it should be and it is clear that last night's performance wasn't considered. LA said that he is a man of principal but that would tell me that he would vote for the best performance from last night. That is NOT considered as integrity. Nicole totally let America down. Simon it is time to replace two of the judges.
posted by Stupidnicole on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole fake cow !
posted by Doyerjob on Dec 09, 2011
2 weeks in a row Nicole blew it.
posted by deebronx on Dec 09, 2011
rachel crowe was a basket case too immature you promised mom she was saying what an embarassment kiss disneys interest in her goodbye after that scene
posted by hallini on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel's performance moved me to tears tonight, she gave the better performance and she should have stayed!
posted by Diana on Dec 09, 2011
Rachael Crow is a singer, not a screamer like Marcus. He is always off beat. That was not fair. I am amazed by these two judges who can't judge a dog show. I will not be watching this show any longer. I will wait for American Idol.
posted by bwilliams on Dec 09, 2011
I think Nicole should have did her job and made the choice instead of making it a tie because she didnt want to send someone home. But lets face it that is what they are getting paid for to judge and tonight she did not do that.I also agree if they were going to a tie then america should have voted on the songs from tonight because that is why they were singing tonight to try to save theirselves.Rachel should have not been sent home and eveybody knows it. She should have been in the top 2.Nicole i can not beleive u could not judge tonight knowing who should have went home and i would not of had anything to say after the show either because u know u were wrong.
posted by Mary on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel is exstremly talented. This just proves people need to VOTE. Yes, the save song is there for a reason, but those are the rules. Simon, you better sign that girl!!!!
posted by caymanpete on Dec 09, 2011
Both Nicole & L A have shown how really unprofessional they both are!!!
posted by Jukeco on Dec 09, 2011
I am tired of the judges insulting each other about the way the contestants sing/choice of song. This is not about the judges! It is about the singers!
posted by Jimmer1 on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole is a PHONEY.
posted by Nicolesucks on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole is spineless and a phoney. Simon should fire her and that idiot, LA Reid. Both do not add anything good to the show.
posted by Tbird on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole ruins the show just liked last night.
posted by claire on Dec 09, 2011
What the point of having a save song IF the best performance does not go through ! Rachel gave the best performance last night and should have stay . Nicole tooks Rachel chance to go to the semi final but also to go to the final , as may be she would make it through next week . I think people did not vote because they believe Rachel was safe , i almost did not vote for her AS i believe she was safe , but then i did pick up the phone to vote . The good news for me , i don't have to watch the show anymore !!!! It is a terrible show , it does look like a freak show . Rachel is the only who has the X factor . It is Simon fault if she is going home , he really has not been a good mentor for Rachel Crow .
posted by XfactorJapan on Dec 09, 2011
America voted Rachael the least but for LAST NIGHTS performance. That is why there is a save me song - to redeem oneself. Clearly Rachael destroyed Marcus on this and Nicole should have voted based on this. Her inability or excuse - whatever they may be - goes against what she said last week when she let Drew go. Although it should be, it's not about not letting Marcus thought 3rd time rround, or the fact that Rachael has more potential, but the save me performance! YOU ARE A FOOL NICOLE.
posted by XfaxtorJapan on Dec 09, 2011
America voted Rachael the least but for LAST NIGHTS performance. That is why there is a save me song - to redeem oneself. Clearly Rachael destroyed Marcus on this and Nicole should have voted based on this. Her inability or excuse - whatever they may be - goes against what she said last week when she let Drew go. Although it should be, it's not about not letting Marcus thought 3rd time rround, or the fact that Rachael has more potential, but the save me performance! YOU ARE A FOOL NICOLE.
posted by kay on Dec 09, 2011
All of your crying after effect is nothing. Why did you guys not stay on the phone and vote like I did for Marcus. Things happen tough luck, do not put the blame on Nicole, it is very hard choice, Marcus can deliver (therefore more votes) Do not hate, congratulate. I wish R. Crowe best of luck. She is gonna be fine.
posted by GAIA on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole and LA Reid are you fake judges? Where is your honesty and your fairness to judge Rachel. Simon is a good mentor to Rachel. Good success and long career Angel Rachel.
posted by Ben on Dec 09, 2011
If Nicole can't make a decision then she should be sent home. If you wanted Rachel to win so bad then you should have voted for her more, Really a simple answer. She didn't get enough votes..
posted by NIKKOLEI on Dec 09, 2011
The point of having a sing off is so that the judges can save whoever sang better tonight. Marcus sang good, but we all know Rachel sang way better than he did. If the judges are going to go by votes, then they shouldn't have the sing off. Booooo on Nicole. She knew that Rachel sang way better.
posted by sandybees on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole needs to be FIRED. She threw away her job as judge. She cried, looked all around at LA and Paula...she literally couldn't decide. Marcus wasn't even her mentee. What is going on with her loyalty and tears over Marcus. She knew Rachel sang ten times better than Marcus. Fire the bitch.
posted by Nikko lei on Dec 09, 2011
The point of having a save me song is so that the judges can save whoever sang better tonight. Marcus sang good, but we all know Rachel sang way better than he did. If the judges are going to go by votes, then they shouldn't have the sing off. Booooo on Nicole. She knew that Rachel sang way better.
posted by Markey on Dec 09, 2011
What a farce. Shame on Nicole. Frankly I have never seen the interest in Marcus - he sings off-key. What's the point of having a sing off if the judges leave it up to the previous evenings vote.
posted by rexmax on Dec 09, 2011
What good is a save me song? It cannot save you if it did Rachel would still be there!!! Marcus was in the bottom 3 times in a row doesn't that tell the judges something??? Just because ur a mentor doesn't mean vote for ur own you vote for who deserves to win...Rachel sang much better than Marcus on the save me song!!!!!!!!!!
posted by lanka 9 on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole's actions are stupid. She is not fit to be a judge. I do not know why Simon hired her. She is trying to be smarter than Simon. she should understands who she is. Nicole, your actions show how stupid you are.
posted by slbx on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole, what were you thinking? If you dont have the courage to step up and make the right call...Stay home next year...PLEASE!
posted by Patricia on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel is a phoney ,too immature to withstand this business. Wow telling her mommy that you promised me ,what that she would win the whole contest Dont pick this girl up,shes horrible and a brat.
posted by SirSon on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole did the right thing ...she obviously liked them both so she let YOU "AMERICA" make the decision... and AMERICA didnt vote for RACHEL...and now everybody is cryinnngg.... I think Rachel was great...but theres a reason why she got the least amount of votes... the reason is SIMON!!! he didnt choose the song the get the best out of her... but she will be fine. We will def hear from her...
posted by 2NCKI on Dec 09, 2011
I watched the X Factor from the 1st show and it was good and the singers were very good but last night's show was kinda heartbreaking to see Rachel fall out and cry like that. Something went wrong and the viewers should not have to witness these kind of breakdowns. I was disappointed cause Rachel can sing! Marcus should have a sore throat today cause he really did hit some notes way out of his range and strained his voice badly. Don't wanna see babygirl cry like that, ever again,too painful.....
posted by Ange on Dec 09, 2011
I thought Rachel is going to win the x factor... N may be Chris Rene ..close call. Why is marcus still in the game ?? This show is getting stupid ..
posted by Sickened on Dec 09, 2011
If Nicole is too "fragile" to want to hurt the feelings of a contestant, she shouldn't be a judge. Her histrionics made me sick and poor Rachel the paid for her pathetic display. I have no doubt that Rachel will be fine and someone will snap her up pretty quickly if they have any sense.
posted by Sichilima on Dec 09, 2011
Not Nicole`s fault. As a judge she can abstain and give the power to the `jury` who is YOU the voters. And she did just that. I was refused a recording deal when I was 15yrs old which was hard to take in but now I`m medical doctor.
posted by patton on Dec 09, 2011
LA Reid admitted Rachel was the better singer! Nicole and LA simply need to do their jobs. The purpose of a judge is to make difficult decisions and if they cannot, get rid of them. It is NOT fair what they both did to Rachel. Simon, you should take a hard look at how judges are conducting themselves and playing with kids lives just because of the principle of the matter or because they do not want to make that difficult decision. Simon you are going to lose the audience if this crap keeps up. IT is a talent show, not a personality show! What a joke...
posted by Zaalus on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole is worthless. Paid to do a job and fails. I'm not a fan of Rachel or Marcus. But if I had someone who was in the bottom 2 for 3 weeks in a row and someone who never was, I'd think it's kinda obvious who sucks more
posted by jitiberi on Dec 09, 2011
Nichole went for the "drama" not the talent. She wanted to milk her time in the spotlight. It was not supposed to be about you Nichole, it was supposed to be about the contestants and we all know who did the best job on the save songs!
posted by tiamia on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole has no spine and to me it was spitefully done because she doesnt like Simon
posted by sadiemae30 on Dec 09, 2011
Why do they have a save song anyway? Why don't they just do it like AI and go with the lowest votes? It gets the contestants hopes high and it does not work. I believe Marcus would have been sent home 3 weeks ago if that were the case. He's an ok singer but not that strong. And I think everyone needs to leave Nicole alone already. Rachel is a sweet girl but a little spoiled. She is so young and has her life ahead of her. She will go places. I must admit that with her and Drew gone now, I will only watch Melanie perform next week. And if she goes, that will be it for me. Of the 3 guys, Josh has it all over the other 2. Big time. Experience, soul, life.
posted by Joel on Dec 09, 2011
Wow did u c what I saw a young girl very talented, that sung her whole heart out.. Marcus sung good..good..he said he was going to sing his heart out, well he fell short to Rachel...If ur a judge and u were judging that performance really..L.A. Really Nicole...I understand the deadlock and wat its for.but Rachel sung her heart out..
posted by GotXed on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel sang ger heart out on the save me song and blew away Marcus. It's sad that the save me song doesn't do what it is supposed to do. Rachel got the aXe.
posted by Architect74 on Dec 09, 2011
I think that if someone is being paid to do a job such as judge a save me song performance, and that person doesn't do it, Nicole, then they shouldn't have the job of a judge anymore. How much money is Nicole making just to cry and jump around during performances? Sounds like she is an overpaid, glorified FAN to me. Do your job or go home!
posted by shsfa on Dec 09, 2011
Simon, Get rid of LA and Nicole. They are worthless.
posted by manmasb on Dec 09, 2011
Simon, Fire LA and Nicole.
posted by tick on Dec 09, 2011
LA Reid and Nicole must go.
posted by SNOWFLAKE on Dec 09, 2011
What a scam. Rachel is so talented and Marcus is one of the weakest vocalists on this show. SO FIXED. LA Reid set her up and Nicole killed her off. Simon had a concerned look on his face because he dreaded her reaction when she got sent home. I feel like I wasted so many weeks watching this fiasco. Rachel was robbed and Marcus will go down next week, as he should have this week.
posted by candybar on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel was not being a brat if you paid attention you would have heard her mom say it will be alright I promise and Rachel mommy you promise me you promise me get your facts straight..By the way she is still a child but acted better than Nicole did , she was way better than Marcus could ever be
posted by GMAN on Dec 09, 2011
Big mistake and disappointment.... Rachel, keep your headup, you're a winner... She should have definitely been in the top 3 along with Josh and Melanie... We (the audience) was led to beleive that the purpose of the "Save Me Song" is to be judged on that performance and not by previous ones. If not, then waht purpose is it serving? Seems the judges are not living up to the rules set.
posted by fairgame on Dec 09, 2011
Okay. I agree that Rachel out performed Marcus in Vocals, Performance, and Charisma. She is amazing. I believe Nicole did her a favor. How you say. Now this gives the producers the opportunity to bid for her amazing talent. Simon has done well as her mentor. So, let's not feel sorry for her, or be so vicious toward Nicole. Let's applaud Rachel's near future success. So little, enjoy the ride and much success to you and your family.
posted by rosie on Dec 09, 2011
So it happened. Rachel was voted off by the American Voters. I agree that she out performed Marcus in Performance, Charisma, Vocals, and Enthusiasm. She should have been saved. But, I think Nicole did Rachel a big favor. How, it now gives all those producers who will be after her on opportunity to bid for her. Lucky she has Simon for a mentor. Watch out Rachel, you are a hot item. Good luck little one.
posted by Tiana on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole isn't spineless because she "didn't make a decision". Her decision was to let America decide who they wanted to go through and Marcus had the most votes. To me, that is fair. And Rachel is an amazing singer but she isn't mature enough to deal with being a celebrity. It's not like every singer always has gigs and is always selling records; a lot of the time they get told no. And she just showed that she can't handle being told no. I'm not blaming her for it she's 13 but I think there's a reason why there are no more kids on the show: they are not mature enough to handle a music career. When the older people went home they just accepted it even though it was worse for them because they have more to lose and less time to make it big. But Drew, Rachel, and Astro (the 1st time) just lost it and you cannot do that when something doesn't go your way.
posted by TDFC on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole isn't spineless because she "didn't make a decision". Her decision was to let America decide who they wanted to go through and Marcus had the most votes. To me, that is fair. And Rachel is an amazing singer but she isn't mature enough to deal with being a celebrity. It's not like every singer always has gigs and is always selling records; a lot of the time they get told no. And she just showed that she can't handle being told no. I'm not blaming her for it she's 13 but I think there's a reason why there are no more kids on the show: they are not mature enough to handle a music career. When the older people went home they just accepted it even though it was worse for them because they have more to lose and less time to make it big. But Drew, Rachel, and Astro (the 1st time) just lost it and you cannot do that when something doesn't go your way.
posted by ZELDA on Dec 09, 2011
X FACTOR IS A GOOD SHOW. JUDGES CAN YOU PLAY FAIR? RACHEL I WISH YOU THE BEST AND A LONG CAREER.
posted by dedeJ on Dec 09, 2011
LA set up Rachel on the performance night by talking about people swarming around her to make her an offer. He said he was not suppose to say it, but he did with the idea of suppressing her votes. People voted for others because they thought she would be taken care of. LA is a calculating guy.
posted by keepin_it_real on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole's not to blame. Rachel should've stayed but, you didn't vote america. So get over it. Simon's gonna sign her anyway.
posted by Fufu00 on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole is a waste of space, what does she know about being talented. She was in the pussycat dolls... shows so much about her. Nicole should be off the show right now and say to good bye to her career.
posted by TONY on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel is a better singer than Marcus. Nicole and LA Reid decision were too superficial to send Rachel home. Rachel sings from her heart and I wish her a long career and be blessed.
posted by Ben Dover on Dec 09, 2011
I just want to know... do those of you who cry "I'm not watching the X-Factor anymore" REALLLY think anyone gives a crap?
posted by cogle.s on Dec 09, 2011
Poor little Rachel...she was wayyyy better than Marcus. Nicole should harden up and do what's she's paid to do and actually judge the performances...I can see josh going as payback!!!
posted by ACESHOWBIZ on Dec 09, 2011
Shame on you NICOLE!!!!
posted by clx_mom on Dec 09, 2011
Rachek was amazing. She was the only reason we watched this show. Nicole you know Rachel performed way better than Marcus! If you can't cook get out of the kitchen
posted by Ex-XFactor Fan on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel is very talented and should have a great career. Nicole should have done her job and not wimped out. Didn't Paula do the same thing a few weeks ago? They need to change this unfair rule. Rachel is young and yet mature. How she was able to sing that last song through her tears just shows that she has the talent to go far. She is amazing!
posted by kuokie on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel was the only reason to watch the show.Guess now I watch American Idol.No moe X factor
posted by sweetlady on Dec 09, 2011
Is Nicole a judge? I am done watching x factor. Rachel is a beautiful person with amazing character and talent. She gave an outstanding performance! This did not have to happen. Isn't this why they have this safety net, so these situations won't occur? Rachel should have been in the finals!!!! Ridiculous...
posted by BeReal on Dec 09, 2011
Rachel - Star with the X-Factor....Marcus - A dime a dozen...
posted by KC Clarke on Dec 09, 2011
Nicole, do you know what the responsibilities of a judge are? Obviously not, your act was cowardly tonight, you just told America not to stand up and be counted, but to cowardly pass the buck. You should be dismissed as a judge for neglect of duty. Had you voted and she still went home you would have been respected, but you were a coward and because of it, the better of the two singers tonight went home. Shame on you.
posted by jose on Dec 09, 2011
Based on Rachael reaction, she was too immature for this contest, plus America decided to send her home, not Nicole!
posted by trisha on Dec 09, 2011
Thing is Nicole made her decision, the judges should have to make the decision for the final two, it should be america's votes and rachel got the least votes, don't get me wrong I love Rachel but the point America did not vote her in, she will make it tho, she is awesome:)
posted by Mumani on Dec 09, 2011
seriously?!?!? Won't be watching the show again......the 'x' that they're looking for is the controversy they're creating. Nicole is a fake. The save me songs were easy to judge. Rachel rocked it!!!
posted by Critically acclaimed on Dec 09, 2011
Can we stop blamming the judges and start asking why Americans still voting for Chris Renae.
posted by Kew1253 on Dec 09, 2011
I am surprised that there are those who called her a brat. Wow, we adults who are immature expect a 12/13 yr old to act as we do. News Flash "She is not an adult" - she is however, talented, has grace and as was said the other day, an old soul in a young person. She never failed to blow me away with her singing ability. Rachel will soar far above those on the show including the judges. You Go Girl!!
posted by pr5 on Dec 09, 2011
Talented kid. But the music business is a "business" and the sharks will chew her up. After watching her meltdown, I don't think Rachel is ready for that.
posted by Shameful on Dec 08, 2011
only fair thing of going to Americas vote would've been Americas vote on the save me song cuz then what's the point of the save me song if one person does so much better than the other and loses by supposed votes on a previous performance. They should've done a live audience vote and a new America vote for the save me song. Can't believe they let one or he top favorites go out like this. Damn you American I voted for Rachel but after this I will not be watching or voting again .
posted by 2cool85 on Dec 08, 2011
some1 had to be the bad guy and Nicole took the fall, it a production guys no matter how real you think it is....wising up....the world knows that Rachel spanked Marcus, even he knows that...lol be she bout to blow up and have her own show this spring lol and he is adios next week lol,,,,
posted by Sherryb on Dec 08, 2011
I demand a recount!
posted by DaddysGirl on Dec 08, 2011
Bring back the other judge from the U.K. She's obviously better equipped for the job!
posted by Nicole on Dec 08, 2011
Can't believe Nicole shattered the poor girls dreams like that by not judging fairly on the save me showdown and choosing to make it a tie . Even Reid said he has to vote for Marcus cuz its his guy and Rachel outdid him. Hopefully Nicole is replaced by a more emotionally stable good singer judge. Rachel was the xfactor! Very disappointmented.
posted by rikrin on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole has to go -- America's decision!
posted by mre9 on Dec 08, 2011
I agree that rachel was better on the save me song. i also think that going into deadlock is the honorable thing to do in letting america decide. however, it should have been done last week with drew and marcus. too many double standards and biases on this show
posted by Rosie on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole you are vengeful and stupid...You went of your evil emotions to retaliate against Simon and didnt do the right thing for Rachel....You have to go...!!!
posted by Gayle on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole you are stupid and childish. You did put an end to Rachel Crow on X Factor but she will be the end of you on everything. I am going to boycott X Factor (my favorite show) and I may boycott FOX Network if they keep you on. FOX, bring Rachel back or release Nicole before morning. She deserves the same hurt that she inflicted on Rachel. Guess she hadn't suffered enough in life, huh?
posted by Annek11 on Dec 08, 2011
UNBLEVIEBLE!!!! Nicole is a coward!!!!! I will never watch this show again and if Nicole had have done her job then Rachel would still be in Xfactor!!! Don't know if Nicole really understood the definition of 'judging' ...obiviously not unless she thought she had to just turn up and talk shite ...cause that's all she did!!! Rachel was brilliant tonight as always and if Nicole had've done the job that she's being extremely well paid for then Marcus would be the one to have left...shame on you Nicole!!!
posted by ROZIE on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole is very selfish and vengeful..she didnt consider Rachel"s talent..she went off Simons cruelty!! But it will back fire on her!!!
posted by rod on Dec 08, 2011
Wrong again Nicole, we need a new judge in Nicole place
posted by WHATTHE on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole ruined the whole show with her inability to make a decision on the save song where Rachel cleary blew this guy away. Does LA Reid own Nicoles music career or something. It's like she sold out and didn't make the eight fair decision. Deadlock is only if they had both sang just as good for a tie. But clearly that wasn't the case
posted by Renegade44 on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole is payed to Judge talent. She is to decide who goes and stays. If she can't do her job, she needs to leave.
posted by NYCFinest on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole ruined the whole show with her inability to make a decision on the save song where Rachel cleary blew this guy away. Does LA Reid own Nicoles music career or something. It's like she sold out and didn't make the eight fair decision. Deadlock is only if they had both sang just as good for a tie. But clearly that wasn't the case
posted by MaryA on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole knew Rachel was the best but she didn't have the courage to go against LA Reid (did you notice how she kept looking at him?). The entire show has turned into a contest and fight between the judges...the entire thing has turned into a joke!
posted by SoSad on Dec 08, 2011
It is a sad day when a grown woman cares more about how she feels about having to make a decision because it was too upsetting for her...she had little regard for the fact that her decision was going to screw over the most talented contestant. I thought the point behind the judges was to judge...to make the decision. I like Nicole but clearly she is too emotionally cripple to handle this job.
posted by commess on Dec 08, 2011
I can't believe people. What's wrong with you all? We all enjoyed Rachel it's true, absolutely talented,wonderful entertainer, but AMERICA sent her home. Whatever is all the hating and threatening Nicole about? Please let's stop being so silly. Rachel is going places man, watch and see!
posted by xxxxx on Dec 08, 2011
At this point in the season, it is clear that Nicole is the one that needs to go home. I'm a fan of the show, but I'm done watching her. I will literally fast forward through all of her appearances because she never has anything worthwhile to say, as was evident tonight. Rachel, you are amazing, talented and superb.
posted by ihatenicolesherzinge on Dec 08, 2011
I can't believe nicole did that....Rachel is WAY better than marcus and she did better then him on the save me song! Nicole Sherzinger SUCKS!
posted by crafty1 on Dec 08, 2011
Nicole you will pay for this!
posted by DEBBIE on Dec 08, 2011
How unfair! I was extremely disappointed with Nicole's inability to make a good decision. In fact, it is disappointing that the mentors can't see beyond themselves and judge the contestants honestly. I will not be watching this show next year.
posted by cmg735 on Dec 08, 2011
Rachel was my favorite, guess I'm done watching X Factor.
posted by Baybay25 on Dec 08, 2011
I dont think Rachel should have gone home. She is an amazing singer and I love her.

Screen Name
Please Enter   
Comment
 
 
 
RSS
FB
Twitter