Jake Pavelka chose Tenley and Vienna to be in the final two and decided that Ali should not come back to the show despite her plea.
Gia makes her exit from "The Bachelor" season 14 when Jake Pavelka did not hand her a rose. This leaves the final two between 'fans favorite' Tenley and 'villain' Vienna. "To send Gia home was just horrible for me. ...I made her cry and it just broke my heart," Jake said. "I hate that I hurt someone that I love."
Earlier in the night, the three girls joined Jake in a trip to St. Lucia where they each get a solo date. Gia was the first. Jake took her for lunch in a local restaurant and he bought her a necklace. They watched the sunset on the beach and started making out before heading their way to Snuggler's Cove where they intend to have dinner.
Jake said that he wanted to take care of Gia and she told him how great a human being he is. He then handed her the card to the fantasy suite where they enjoy a bubble bath together. Jake later confessed that Gia has captured his heart.
The second date was with Tenley. They took a helicopter ride to the middle of a rainforest to have a picnic. Tenley, who was once married, asked him about what marriage means to him. Jake said, "When I fall in love, I can look you in the eye 40 years later and tell you I still have that little boy crush on my wife." They had dinner later and danced.
He also gave her the fantasy suite card which she was reluctant to accept at first because it would be her first with a man since divorcing her ex-husband. When she arrived, the place was scattered with rose petals but they made out in the pool instead.
The last date was with Vienna. They boarded a ship which was used in the "Pirates of the Carribean" series and had a playful time together. Jake put on an eyepatch and teased her. They laid on the deck for a sunbath and they jumped off the plank for a quick dive. They made out in the water.
During dinner, Jake asked Vienna about what kind of future she pictured. She said she was ready for marriage but not children yet. "Could you see me as your wife?" she asked and Jake replied, "You wouldn't be here if I couldn't."
Then came the call from the past. Ali, who was in San Francisco, told him that she made the safe choice but not the right choice when she left last week. She wanted back on the show even if he would send her home right away. Jake said he "wanted" to have her back but felt it not right. He didn't want to send home one of the three women to have her back. So Ali was left heartbroken after the phone call.
Before the rose ceremony, Jake watched video messages from the three women. Tenley said, "I dream of dancing with you forever. I believe that we can have that fairy-tale ending." Gia said, "I can honestly say to you, right now, that I am falling in love with you." Vienna said, "You mean the world to me, and I can't wait to be your wife," adding she wants to flirt with him in the next 80 years.
Time to hand out the rose. Jake said he has fallen to each of the women and handed out the roses to Tenley and Vienna. "It was not easy," Jake told Gia. "I think you're absolutely amazing. ...I just felt like I developed a little bit stronger feelings for the other two women."
Gia replied, "I know that I haven't been the most open. I know that I'm slow moving at this... There's two other great girls there and... I totally understand. And If they weren't great girls, I would sit here and tell you that you made the wrong decision. I don't think you did, so I'm happy for you." In the limo, Gia said she was "crushed".
Jake turned to Vienna and Tenley, saying he could see a future with them. In the next episode, these two will be taken to two different parts of the island and meet Jake's family. However, this will air two weeks from now for a Women Tell All session will be aired next week.