WHAT'S HOT?

Matt Giraud Eliminated From 'American Idol', Adam Lambert in Bottom 3

April 30, 2009 02:20:51 GMT

Beside the axing of Matt Giraud, the result show of 'American Idol' revealed a shocking upturn as Adam Lambert was placed on the bottom three.
Matt Giraud Eliminated From 'American Idol', Adam Lambert in Bottom 3
See larger image

It was a surprising line up of the bottom three this week in "". Many have predicted that either Matt Giraud or will be the least voted but they only got one right. Matt was in the bottom three along with and surprisingly, fan and judges favorite, .

announced that there were 47 million votes cast on the Rat Pack night. Then later he started dividing the top 5 into two groups. Matt was grouped with Kris and Adam on right side of the stage while Allison and stood on the left side. The host then announced that Matt's group belonged to the bottom three.

Kris was first to be declared safe, leaving Adam and Matt for the climax toward the end of the show. Seacrest finally said that Matt, who was saved by judges two weeks prior, is not in the top 4.

The result night on Wednesday, April 29 invited several guest performers including that became the mentor of the week. Others were and former "Idol" champion .



Post Your Comments

posted by hestinksagain on May 05, 2009
well, adam stuck again tonight. stop looking into the camera and lip syncing thank you to the judges. pathetic.
posted by hockeymom1977@aol.co on May 04, 2009
I have watched AI since season 2 and there have been some strange things. I am a mother of 5 all in college and am an Adam fan. I do not care about his sexual preferences. Obviously his parents, family and friends love him and that is what counts. He is indeed an amazing talent and I have already downloaded many of his tunes. You say he is predictable; well I feel he changes weekly! You say he is not growing; well he is and if he was a true entertainer in the beginning then he is just showing he is an even better entertainer. I indeed want him to win and will not watch the show if he doesn't anymore but win or loose he will be the winner because he will be as famous as Carrie or other superstars and so will the public for the talent of his gifts.
posted by angelgold on May 04, 2009
i cant belive adam was in the buttom 3.he is the best voice . i dont understand the people who voted the others..i am going to buy his cd's because all his songs is so beautiful...pls give your votes for ADAM........
posted by beeboop on May 03, 2009
Ryan Seacrest needs to go or at least stop acting like a jerk who asks very weird questions and makes comments that a strange! The way he handled Adam Lambert last week just proves how arrogant Seacrest can be! Is this just Seacrest or AI telling him what to say? What some see as arrogance in Adam is really just confidence! He believes in his talents and we should too. Dummy up, Seacrest!
posted by Jean on May 03, 2009
rry to say this but it's true. Adam was definetely in the bottom 2. Votes were not good enough for him this week. Many of his fans had admited they splitted their votes others thought he was safe and voted for the one they didnt wanted to go, for sympathy. This mistake nearly cost Adam his place in AI. A mistake it has to be rectified so fans and America from now on no more sympathy votes or you could lose the real talented guy, the one who deserves to win. Adam Lambert is the winner no doubt about it so vote for him!!!
posted by brainygirl on May 03, 2009
I really suspect the voting was RIGGED in order to get higher ratings. I taped the show and voted later that night; when I called in for the other contestants, I had no problem calling in, however, when I tried to vote for Adam, BOTH numbers were BUSY for about half an hour, which indicates to me that he had FLOODED the phone lines. I couldn't vote because I just didn't have two hours to sit on the phone...the whole thing seems fishy to me. Adam is brilliant and deserves to WIN!
posted by ARdweller on May 03, 2009
Both Seacreast and Adam are secret lovers...both need to go. ADAM....STOP looking at the damn camera all the time. BTW, it's not confidence, it's being vein. Adam biggest fan is Adam, plain and simple.
posted by Me on May 02, 2009
Adam will be a world entertainer. The other 3 contestants (whats their names?) will have only 15 minutes of fame...lol
posted by Lorilie on May 02, 2009
Plain and simple...."ratings stunt". Shame on you for doing that to Adam. He is your winner!
posted by FRMFRD on May 02, 2009
You know what's too funny. Simon tells the others to have more stage presence...move around, interact with the audience. Then how come when Adam just stands or sits in one place and sings under a spot light the judges think it's increadable? NOT SO MUCH JUDGES. That's why Adam is in the bottom 3!! As the other blogger said..the judges heads are up Adams -SS! go danny gockey!
posted by Surferdudexoxo on May 02, 2009
WOW...all the Adam haters out there! I LOVE IT!>> It about time we threw PC out the window. Love the sour milk comparison. More sounds like nails on a chalk board. screeeech!
posted by jjkingery on May 02, 2009
What is up with looking into the camera all the time? The judges heads are so far up....he is irrogant and cocky. Glad to see him at the bottom 2. Try playing back the part when he was told he is in the bottom 3. His face was priceless!! Irrogant to think he "belonged" in the group with Danny. Just goes to show you he is cocky and irrogant. Who needs another star like that in Hollywood. Bout time we get some good old fashioned NORMAL and THANKFUL people in Hollywood.
posted by buzyforu2 on May 02, 2009
TOTALLY. ADAM
posted by AIfantoo on May 02, 2009
i agree, Adam is very predictable and his songs all sound alike. What's with always looking at the camera? And the silent lipping "THANK YOU" to the judges?! What a kiss arse! Go back to the theatrical stage....where the freaks are.
posted by sourmilk on May 02, 2009
SOUR MILK YELL that is. All if his songs have the sour milk trademark! It's getting old (like sour milk)...if he is such an artist...then mix it up...all his songs start to sound the same and are VERY predictable. All milk has an expiration date...just like Adam.
posted by sourmilk on May 02, 2009
Does Adam need to 'scream' his sour milk tune every freaking song he sings? Come on! He is a good singer, but when he screams out his sour milk yell...it just ruins the song. NOT every song needs the sour mild yell! GO DANNY!
posted by AdamBlows on May 01, 2009
literally. Here's to him making an early exit! Go Danny!
posted by vote for adam on May 01, 2009
Dont stop vote for Adam, please. He is amazing! If he will in the bottom 3 next week, I will not watch AI any more!!
posted by shizz on May 01, 2009
NO WAY! Ugh. It ruined my entire friggin day, I seriously thought Matt and Alisson (spelling wrong?) would be the bottom 2, So I started wondering who would be the other one, since Kris, Danny, and Adam had never been in the bottom 3. NO WAY IN MY LIFE I expected that Adam would be the one (and kris). UGH! And Ryan or whoever set you up to ask that question, that was totally NOT cool. If this was a "fake" result... , There's no right rude word for all of this. I wish I lived in the states! I had never watched Idol so consistently before,but the moment I saw Adam audition at San Fransisco and sing a queen song, AND heard that he was in the cast of wicked.I totally fell in love with his talent, his voice and the way he can emotionally connect with alot of songs. So guys, PLEASE PLEASE vote for Adam.
posted by julie on May 01, 2009
is madness to see adam in the bottom 2.America should be serious from now onwards.Is true no split voting or lazy from now on!! Must vote for adam every week!!He need your support,America!!!.Why?,bcuz he deserve to be an American Idol.Not Danny,Alison or Kris.So vote for ADAMMMMMM!!!!!!!!
posted by adam is my idol on Apr 30, 2009
i think they rigged it. i mean theres no way he would be in the bottm 2, or even the bottom 3! and even if he was in the bottom 3, theres NO WAY it was bottom 2. they probly did that for dramatic effect. i hte seacrest hes so sadist.
posted by Lisak on Apr 30, 2009
I think now that people saw Adam in the bottom 2, It gave them a good scare, and they'll vote even more now. GO ADAM LAMBERT!
posted by Adam\'s #1 Fan on Apr 30, 2009
I TOOK THIS PERSONAL! I AM FURIOUS AND THIS SOOO HAS TO BE FIXED FOR THE DAMN DRAMA. IT WAS ALL IN SIMON'S FACE. I HEARD ON MY LOCAL RADIO STATION (KWIN 99.7) THAT SOMETHING HAPPENED WITH ITUNES WHERE ACCIDENTALLY SOMETHING WAS LEAKED ... SHOWING ADAM & KRIS WERE THE FINALISTS. IF ADAM IS ON THE BOTTOM AGAIN - I WILL CREATE A NATION WIDE RIOT/STRIKE.
posted by Cynthia Rose-Martin on Apr 30, 2009
It took David Cook to get me to even consider watching Idol again. They lost a lot of viewers many seasons ago and have been trying to "change things up" to get those viewers back. I came into this season a Danny fan, but was quickly converted to Adam. He is the superior talent without question. The problem with Idol is, they usually get it wrong. If Idol was not rigged for ratings because it was SO OBVIOUS since the top ten started that Adam would win, then this means HIS (Adam's) fans got lazy and weren't voting like they should because he was such a clear front winner. I think they need to change the voting anyway. It should be more like Dancing with the Stars. Half the votes come from the viewers and half the judges. You would have more consistency in the winners. Last but not least the "save" they used on Matt was ridiculous. Going into the finals is when a saved should be used. Simon ALWAYS gets it right and he clearly stated Matt could not win so why save him. This was the first time I (and many of my over 40 girlfriends) actually considered going to an Americal Idol tour to see this young man (Adam) Look up the Los Angeles times article on his mid range voice, the transition from chest to head resonation and read how many people in the world now or EVER have that kind of talent, range, and transition. Then you will realize what you are seeing in this extraordinary young man. He doesn't really need Idol now, but it would be nice if IDOL could finally take credit for someone like him.
posted by well well well on Apr 30, 2009
If they rigged the votes I don't think they would have told Allison or any contestant before the show. It would make a much better show if the contestants seemed as shocked as the viewers.
posted by well well well on Apr 30, 2009
Adam - who would've known? I'm guessing he got the 3rd highest amount of votes last night. Not that surprising that Danny beat Adam this week. But Allison? I'm so happy for her. She was easily my favorite of the night & I felt the most connected with her song. Her best performance yet, I love her softer, sadder (non angry) side. With Lil & Anoop gone a significant chunk of their fans must have latched onto her as their 2nd favorite. I thought she'd benefit from Lil going, I wasn't sure about Anoop's fans. Kris is my favorite & he did well (doesn't everyone at this stage in the competition?) but too boring & didn't stand out. Allison deserved to beat him last night. Adam, Adam. This was my least favorite performance by him. Too staged, with the red carpet & white suit, I couldn't connect with the song or with Adam [it didn't help that they hardly ever did close ups of his face]. I did love his last note though, that was incredible. It felt like we'd seen what Adam showed us last night several times before from him, & simply, done much better. Adam is still 'the one'. He was my early favorite & I really hope he wins over Danny. On the other hand I wouldn't put it past them to meddle with the votes (because this season is - unfortunately for Idol addicts - Idols lowest viewer rate so far). Kris, looking forward to what you'll bring next week!! I'm holding out hope for a Kris-Adam finale (if only). How come Danny has so many fans? I don't like his style & loud voice, I want to see him go next week (if only). I thought for sure that Kris would make it into the top 3 because he has never been in the bottom (until now!) while Allison has been in the bottom 3 times, and Matt 2 times. Now suddenly, Allison has greatly increased her fan base.
posted by hammer19 on Apr 30, 2009
there is no way adam was voted into the bottom 3...this is just AI vying for ratings.
posted by James on Apr 30, 2009
This had to be a set up. He's the best american idol contestant there has ever been. if he doesnt win then you know american idol is fraud. Danny sucks he is another Taylor Hicks. can you get any lamer.
posted by Susan on Apr 30, 2009
I'm actually glad. I love Adam but now the show is more fun to watch since maybe someone else could possibly beat Adam. Although, he is way above the other singers.
posted by sarah on Apr 30, 2009
*shocked* i mean, he totally rocked the stage, how could he be bottom 3?!! if only i lived in america, vote him a 100 times for every performance :) pls, don't ever..ever let him be bottom 3 again, it completely ruined my day..vote for him guys! this guy has talent!
posted by mysticlari on Apr 30, 2009
The producers are messing with the votes for thrill factor. Adam is number 1! Allison should have been in bottom 3, but they were not honest with the votes to – shake things up a bit. Next week, will probably be their biggest vote and ratings. That’s what they do in that industry. Here’s the thing, I have never blogged or taken part in any internet discussions because I am too busy. I am a 44 year old mother and work FT. I’ve seen it all and been thru it all and know talent. My husband is a musician. We are in AWE of Adam Lambert. I’ve never believed in all the fuss and show of being “a fan”. Some people are awesomely talented, but we are all special in our own way. I’ve never even written fan mail. But I would for Adam! This man is amazing. I’ve been waiting for new talent like him since the greats like Led Zep, Doors, Aerosmith, Police, Stones, Rush, Clapton, Lenny Kravitz, Annie Lenox; and I’ve enjoyed (felt relief) in some of the newer talents in last decade like Maroon 5, Beck, Cold Play, Alicia Keys, Carrie Underwood, and the ever quiet Maxwell (we need more from you). I will vote for Adam next week. I’ve never voted on Idol before, but I will to save my guy. I’m sure he’s intelligent enough this week to balance any overconfidence he may have had (didn’t seem like it, doom of any entertainer), and choose the right Rock song (what the heck will that be?!). He’ll come thru to the end. He is the most talented person ever on Idol. I cannot wait for his first CD. Everyone loving this guy needs to vote and support him! I also WILL NEVER watch Idol again if he does not win. Quit messing with us Idol! Just crown King Lambert and let it be done. Let us enjoy this guy no matter what his personal choices to the fullest extent for the next 50 years!
posted by Gerry on Apr 30, 2009
Could this sudden surge in votes from 33 million to 53 million be the result of Bill O'Reilly's letting his conservative listeners know that a "gay" might be an American Idol? Where did these new votes come from?
posted by Bizarro7 on Apr 30, 2009
It was totally bogus, a ploy by AI to keep everyone tuned in the entire hour, watching the commercials. I think it was staged and that some were warned ahead of time so that they would be prepared (possibly even Adam).
posted by Microfuzz on Apr 30, 2009
If Adam had gone home, I really would like to hope that the whole building would erupt and there would be a crazy riot. And the judges would get up and walk away. I would. I would. And by the way everyone, if the votes WERE rigged, as few people would be told as possible. Definatly not the contestants, definatly not the judges, and probably not even Ryan.
posted by Not Important on Apr 30, 2009
Okay, this is what it boils down to...Adam is way and beyond!!! A talented ARTIST that no one could have ever imagined....way above perfection and versatility... who was to think that a human with so much GOD GIVEN talent would exist in out day and age...WINNER?,,, is an understatement...the only thing that would positively come out of him not winning would be the % of $$$ less given to whom not for merit... he deserves it all, and I mean ALL for for HIS own unique talent and persistance. Adam, YOU ARE GREAT!!!
posted by love adam on Apr 30, 2009
adam rocks can easy sing for groups like queen nd guns n roses nd be so famous. adam rules hope slash sees that next week
posted by george england on Apr 30, 2009
oh my... no way...i m 38 living in greece adam lambert can sing easy for queen or guns n roses ..hope slash next week makes him an offer or may from queen...adam lambert rocks
posted by aiwatcher on Apr 30, 2009
I think everyone thought Adam was safe and voted for other contestants to keep them from being eliminated. Goes to show... EVERY vote counts. Plus, two very conservative singers were eliminated last week and you don't know who they decided to vote for. Maybe not Adam?
posted by grannygreyhair07@aol on Apr 30, 2009
Iknow it was rigged because Paula loves Adam and she was not upset at all that he was in the bottom 2. They did it on purpose just to get us Adam fans in a roar. There is now way in hell he would have been in the bottom 3 and really not in the bottom 2. It was all a set up because Paula would have been absoulty out of her mind and she was calm as ever. Adam is so much better than everyone else in the competiton they had to do something to make the other contestants look a little better. Adam Rocks and always will.
posted by AdamAddict on Apr 30, 2009
Please do not let Adam in bottom 2 ever again. I hate the feeling and I hate what Ryan did to Adam.
posted by loveadam on Apr 30, 2009
this is a joke!! Adam lambert in bottom 2??! i'm hoping this is all a fake. Adam has to win it all. OBVIOUSLY HE DOMINATES THIS SEASON. EVERYONE, START VOTING FOR ADAM!!! btw, if he was voted off no one will be watching AI. well at least im not.
posted by don\'t luv adam on Apr 30, 2009
With only 5 left, it was evident that not everyone luvs Adam. I was glad to see him in the bottom 2. He is so full of himself as evidenced by the fact that he was so sure he was in the top 3. He is another Taylor Hicks. He's got a great voice but I can't stand his strutting and screeching.
posted by AI Fan on Apr 30, 2009
This was for drama, Adam is the best talent the show has seen ever and will win it all. If he does not I am done with Idol.
posted by allifan on Apr 30, 2009
I predicted from the beginning that Adam would go all the way because he is SO different. But, different only goes so far before it becomes the same. He's been the same over and over and it's costed him. AI needs artists with diversity. I LOVE Danny Gokey, but if I were to pick it would be Adam and Allison and Adam would win by popularity, not talent.
posted by AdamLambertFORIdol on Apr 30, 2009
Adam should NOT have been the in bottom three, nor the bottom two. That was insane. That gave me a good scare and I think it gave America one too. EVERYONE VOTE ADAM LAMBERT BECAUSE NO ONE IS SAFE.
posted by Nola on Apr 30, 2009
ADAM LAMBERT FANS: DON'T SPLIT YOUR VOTES! VOTE OFTEN!
posted by 123456789 on Apr 30, 2009
I LOVE ADAM. SOMTHING WAS SO WRONG WITH THAT. HES THE BEST IN THE SHOW. MY FAVIRTE RING OF FIRE
posted by musicfan on Apr 30, 2009
If so rare adam is away, American music has no hope! English music will occupy the whole world.American pls open your eyes for wide musical sky.
posted by rock on Apr 30, 2009
Somebody can tell me why adam is in bottom 3? Whether you love him or not, this genius guy did his best every week in bottom 3? Pls tell me why?
posted by adam#1 on Apr 30, 2009
Don't be discouraged Adam. Come back next week and rock our world! WE LOVE YOU!!!!
posted by biglove411 on Apr 30, 2009
Adam in the bottom 2! I couldn't believe it, but Ryan did say that Matt and Adam had the fewest number of votes. Anything is possible in regards to the network playing with the votes. All I know is that I will continue to vote for Adam (alot). He is a vocal angel, and deserves to win AI. Regardless I will be a Adam fan for life and can't wait to see how he presents his art.
posted by adam fan (: on Apr 30, 2009
:O adam in the bottom 3 !! who would of known!! people , you prob thought hes good and he will be safe and you prob didnt vote, well WRONG! never say that, see what happened.. keep voting for adam, i wish i could if i lived in america but i dont so you all need to help him win so dont just give up voting, i hope you seeing him in the bottom 3 warned you :P
posted by ruthee on Apr 30, 2009
It is impossible to believe that the strongest performer AND singer ended up in the bottom 3. Either all of us did not vote (thinking he was safe) or someone tampered with the results. Yes, it probably will increase their ratings. But even the one new judge was stunned. The others are all probably in on the deal.
posted by stunned on Apr 30, 2009
Vote for Adam, America!! VOOOOOOOTEE... and keep on voting until the end of the voting time!!! He deserves to win.
posted by RayAM on Apr 29, 2009
Adam Lambert is definitely the best. I just find it so odd that Allison was repeatedly in the bottom 3 but now Adam Lambert is? AI has been known to be a bit shady. I'm going to re watch it, because Allison didn't seem genuinely surprised about Adam Lambert being in the bottom 3, all I can say is they probably wanted the show to be more interesting, and before the show told Allison they were going to place Adam in the bottom 3 instead of her. Or maybe I'm just blaming AI and the best ever AI contestant was actually in the bottom 3! :(
posted by kiki85 on Apr 29, 2009
I can only assume people thought he'd be safe and didn't vote for him this week. Please vote for Adam!! He is by far the most talented, entertaining, and hottest singer they've ever had!
posted by JJ on Apr 29, 2009
I liked Adam in the beginning, but he's a little too freaky for me. He does have a beautiful voice, but so have lots of others who have gone home.
posted by only1kene on Apr 29, 2009
omg I about shit myself when I learned Adam was in the bottom 3. If he loses, I'll axe AI from here on out. But I'm glad to see Matt go!
posted by luv adam on Apr 29, 2009
omg i cant belive adam was in the bottom 3! its totally wrong, america really screwed up this time he should be the one to win american idol, he is the best one on the show, please vote for adam!!!!!!!

Screen Name
Comment
 
 
 
Follow us on Twitter