WHAT'S HOT?

Two Judges Won't Keep Scott MacIntyre in 'American Idol'

April 09, 2009 06:17:57 GMT

'American Idol' is shed to seven with the departure of legally blind contestant Scott MacIntyre who was deemed by the judges to have picked the wrong song.
Two Judges Won't Keep Scott MacIntyre in 'American Idol'
See larger image

Scott MacIntyre is eliminated from "", leaving seven vying for the title. The contestant who has the eyesight like "seeing from a straw", sang his heart out for another chance but two of the judges won't use their power to keep him in the running. He was thus officially out of the line-up.

Being in the bottom three along with Anoop Desai and Lil Rounds, he got the lowest out of 34 million votes from the audience. He then reprised his performance of 's "The Search Is Over" and made cried. "You've been an inspiration to the entire world," Abdul said. "This was not the right song for you, but it doesn't diminish your talent. You are one classy gentleman."

The judges are allowed to vote whether they want to keep Scott in the competition or not. "Two people think you should stay and two people think you should go. This is really tough," judge Simon Cowell said on the verdict. "Someone's got to make a decision here, and I'm going to say it's the end of the competition. Sorry."

During the result show that was read on Wednesday, April 8, , and Frankie Avalon performed live.

Next week, the remaining seven will be singing tunes from movies and serving as the guest judge is director Quentin Tarantino. Additionally, and have taped performances for next week's result show.



Post Your Comments

posted by Jeanie on Apr 09, 2009
I really like Scott but he can't hang with the others. The votes he received I think were more because of the inspiration that he is and not necessarily because of his singing ability. Great piano player though. God Bless you Scott!

Screen Name
Comment
 
 
 
Follow us on Twitter