The Subtle Knife Comments

i really hope they can afford to make it and there still going to make it if not then i hope someone else will make the subtle knife because i love the book

I will never understand critics. This movie is amazing. It's a shame we will never see the sequels made.

They have to get the sequels done.... we the people need to have this...

the movies has to be made it is the will of many!!!!!! (plz let it be true)

I cant believe anyone was ignorant enough to boycott The Golden Compass! It's insane, I am anxiously awaiting the coming of The Subtle Knife.

I really hope they make the Subtle Knife.... Ive been waiting for this since the first one came out. I think that many people are ignorant and absent minded... With that being said, not everything that youre told is the truth. I had a friend whose pastor told her not to let her daughter watch the movie... (I have 6 kids and we love it!!!) I got my friend to watch it and she was so disappointed in what she was told by her pastor. People are just plain ignorant!

hello everyone, if anyone knows who will play Will Parry please tell (:

Why can't it come out yet! The 3rd Twilight Saga movie is coming out sooner than this is!

I love the book "the subtle knife" but how can you be sure its movie will be released in 2011?

Finally! I hope they get all the same cast and will definately be there opening night! I can not wait for 2010 to be over and find out when the opening night is so I can mark my calendar.

I WANT IT!!! I BEG TO MY KNEES I THINK THAT RELIGIOUS PPLE NEED TO GET OVER IT AND DEAL WITH IT BECAUSE I BELIEVE IN GOD AND I LOVE FANTASY AND EVEN DARK FANTASY AND ITS BEST FANTASY!!!

SUBTLE KNIFE I WANT PLZ MAKE I LOVE YOU I BIG FAN I LOVE YOU PLZ I WANT NOW!! NOWZ PLZ!!

YAH WHAT MY NAME SAID! BRING IT OUT! COME OUT NOOOOWWWW NOWW I SAY NOW! PLZZZZZ I WANT PLZ CAN I HAVE? I LOVE PLZZ!

If you have read the books you realize how controversial the books are to common religious/governmetal control and how putting ideas like that into our world could open eyes. the fact that not even the production agency has bothered to comment on the release of the subtle knife implies that they may not be releasing it. Other classic trilogies were atleast encouraging hype about their next films. If its not agknowledged then the "authority" can make sure it is forgotten... keep that in mind

If I had the money, I would do it myself. This trilogy will turn into a classic, especially when the Amber Spyglass will be filmed. But I guess every business is comparing to the Lord of the Rings' success, hence the delayed production. How sad!

For part of what the controversy is about, is all the more reason that there should be the continuation and completion of this wondrous epic. The Golden Compass was a technically exemplary production with all the qualities of what people enjoy in a movie of this genre. Undoubtedly the sequential productions will be of equal competence and appreciation with this compelling synergistic story. Come on guys, it no longer matters what the others believe. It is almost over. But you still have a little more time to be those courageous entrepreneurs, as like those that make celebrated leaders, forefront in greatness. I am only one of the ten's of millions awaiting your action.

i love this book and i think they should make another one and keep going because whats the point of starting it and then not finishing it. i mean look at harry potter at the 2nd and 1st film it was not that good but then it gets good

I absolutely loved The Golden Compass when it came out though I had never read the books. Now that I have read the books I realize that all the controversy surrounding the movie was retarded. The religious meaning of dust was not truly explored until the second and third books. I think people got the panties all in a bind and as a result kept a truly wonderful trilogy from being created. Let us not forget that a movie is a movie and has to keep the story and flow going for two hours. There is a lot to absorb and I think that for a first movie, the writers and everyone else did a good job... Look at Harry Potter and what they have done to that series to make it something worth watching... not just a good read, totally different mediums. I want to see The Subtle Knife.

i dont think they did mix it up because dont they say something about bolvanger being in Svalbard...i still think it was a good film cant wait for it to come out

sorry about repeating my paragraph but the majouraty should rule am i not correct? but i think lady miaka is right you should end it at that part with her and her father. just would it be posible for a sooner date for the movie to come out

i read up on the internet that this movie was not made when we hoped because of religious belifes well if thats true why not ignore and carry on with what you love because its really what the public wants and not the media right? and dont get me wrong it was a great movie but on the trailer there were some seens i dident see in the movie. when lyra fell off the baloon and others like that can you explain?

i read up on the internet that this movie was not made when we hoped because of religious belifes well if thats true why not ignore and carry on with what you love because its really what the public wants and not the media right? and dont get me wrong it was a great movie but on the trailer there were some seens i dident see in the movie. when lyra fell off the baloon and others like that can you explain?

i read up on the internet that the subtle knife was not made a soon as we hoped because of christian religion since when has that ever stoped annyone before and i mean i agree it ended at the wrong parts there were parts on the trailers i have not seen in the golden compass .. i say get it over with because its what the public wants not the media.

In the process of reading the books and looove them. Can't wait to see the movie adaptation!

when will it ever come out, there's like no news for anything!!!!! hurry up gawd

Despite the differences with the novel, Golden Compass was excellent, I know the sequels will be as well, if they ever get made! I can't wait!!

i really hope this moive is made the golden compass was amazing and i know this one will be to can't wait to see it if it is made

When is The Subtle Knife coming out i really enjoyed The Golden Compas and want to continue watchin the rest

this film will be amazing cause im going to be in it whoo whoo

hQfG7Z

IS THIS MOVIE EVEN GOING TO COME OUT???

there was no point in ending the film where they did, it's only going to mean more work for the next one. and what was with mixing svalbard and bolvanger up?

i was really disappointed in the golden compass. the movie ended at the wrong part and alot of major details were left out. i will continue watching the rest of the series to see how you work around the details left out. but i do have a question, Why end the first movie in the balloon with lee and not at the glacier with her father? it would have made a much better ending.