WHAT'S HOT?
Home > Movie > # > 1911 > Reviews

1911 Reviews

1911

Overview


Genre :

Drama, Historical, Epic

Release Date :

October 07, 2011 (Limited)

MPAA Rating :

R

Director :

Jackie Chan, Zhang Li

Starring :

Jackie Chan, Li Bingbing, Zhao Wen Xuan, Joan Chen, Jaycee Chan, Winston Chao

REVIEWS RATE:  Critics  Not quite bad, but it's not recommended either.    Readers  Be the 1st!

“..they haven't figured out a workable, let alone intelligent, dramatic strategy..”
by Justin Chang [Variety]
“..the film postulates history in such a scrappy, inaccessible manner that either as entertainment or education, it's a lost cause..”
by Maggie Lee [Hollywood Reporter]
“..the film looks splendid, with extraordinary detail and a dynamic sense of action..”
by Andrew L. Urban [Urban Cinefile]
2.5 of 5

“..some of the early battle scenes are exciting, putting viewers right in the middle of the action..”
by Rachel Saltz [New York Times]
“..small matters of characterization, audience identification, and scene-making are entirely absent here..”
by Nick Pinkerton [Village Voice]
2 of 4

“..it's like a comic book on steroids..”
by Greg Quill [Toronto Star]
1.5 of 4

“..it swoops, it pans, it noses around..”
by Mark Feeney [Boston Globe]
2 of 5

“..expository dialogue is epidemic and absurdly stilted..”
by Nick Schager [Time Out New York]

Reader's Reviews


Screen Name
Rate This Movie
Please Enter   
Comment
 
 
 
RSS
FB
Twitter

LATEST REVIEWS

THE CROSSING 2 :

“..an inert follow-up that doesn't deliver enough visual or emotional payoff in its overdue yet short-lived shipwreck climax..”
by Maggie Lee [Variety]

SHAUN THE SHEEP :

“..this is the kind of stuff that has been, and will be, funny forever - built on eternal human fears and foibles that, whatever your age, make complete and hilarious sense..”
by Robbie Collin [Daily Telegraph]

THE END OF THE TOUR :

“..The End Of The Tour largely remains a two-man show, expertly approximating the vagaries of actual conversation-the starts and stops that occur when two strangers are getting to know each other, one sentence at a time..”
by A.A. Dowd [A.V. Club]

NORTHMEN: A VIKING SAGA :

“..Bastian Zach and Matthias Bauer actually have to come up with something other than people shooting, stabbing and bludgeoning each other to death. If only they had put this kind of effort into creating characters worth caring about in the first place..”
by Martin Tsai [LA Times]

JENNY'S WEDDING :

“..ultimately, it becomes more a film about Jenny's parents as they learn to embrace and understand her..”
by Katie Walsh [LA Times]

STATEN ISLAND SUMMER :

“..frustratingly, the movie is plenty likable when it's not trying to show off its wistfulness. As a reader of the fake news, Jost should know that sometimes silly jokes are their own reward..”
by Jesse Hassenger [A.V. Club]

A LEGO BRICKUMENTARY :

“..there isn't much the viewer won't be able to answer about Legos by the end of "A Lego Brickumentary," except, perhaps, why he or she has just watched a 90-minute commercial for Legos..”
by John Anderson [Newsday]

BEST OF ENEMIES :

“..a timely but unsatisfying exploration of a series of exchanges between conservative Buckley and liberal Vidal makes its case too little and too late..”
by Inkoo Kang [The Wrap]

EXTINCTION :

“..if only they had more screen time. The film's core problems: too little zombie and too much plot..”
by Katherine Pushkar [NY Daily News]

THE SEVENTH DWARF :

“..short on charm and utterly devoid of magic..”
by Justin Chang [Variety]